Museum Outreach

As a part of the Museum’s continuous educational outreach programming, this postcard, as seen below, has been developed and is in the process of being distributed to the greater Amherst-area.

Residents of the Amherst area may have seen Col. Nahorn or will see him around town this Fall season personally passing out this postcard – it is a way of introducing himself to our community as a local historian & environmental steward.
Most of our area residents are aware of the Museum, but not everyone is aware of the free quarterly newsletter posted on this website and the educational lectures Col. Nahorn has developed.  The goal is to widen our community outreach and let area residents know about this newsletter and the educational programs that the Museum offers.  A special thank you to local photographer Jason Shaffer for his aid in creating this postcard!


If you are interested in receiving the newsletter and being notified that it has been posted on the website, please visit our Newsletter page to sign up and learn more!  A listing of program offerings is also listed on the Newsletter page.

Oldest in Amherst, Lorain County

The Jacob and Catherine Shupe Homestead, like some serene elder statesman, full of years and confidence, sits well back from the road that was just a narrow trail cut by Jacob Shupe through the woods, more than two hundred years ago.  The previous statement was adapted from an article written about another early Lorain County house, but it fits perfectly here with the Shupe Homestead.  It is further an excerpt from, “The Founding of Early Amherst,” which Col. Nahorn compiled in 2014.  This document, with historically accurate stories, anecdotes, and other researched information describing the early days of Amherst’s founding, is the first of its kind to aggregate such information focusing precisely on the Shupe family; their important contributions to the early years; and the creation of their homestead.  It is available for viewing as a pdf on this website here:


On Sunday, September 25th, at 2pm, while standing on the original sandstone steps of the Shupe Homestead, Col. Nahorn delivered a speech to a group of local historians and other interested individuals gathered directly in front of the house.  The weather was beautiful and perfect for a dedication.  The group was gathered to dedicate and officially unveil the cast aluminum historical marker that has been erected at the base of the Shupe Homestead driveway.

The Nahorn family took possession of and moved into the Shupe House in 1992.  Most people did not know or appreciate the history behind this important site.  Beginning in 1998, spending years of historical research while sifting through tax records, detailed histories, and maps, Col. Nahorn along with his core group of researchers from the New Indian Ridge Museum, including Diane Nahorn and Jeff Sigsworth, determined the Shupe House is the first frame house to have been constructed in Amherst and is likely the oldest frame house in Lorain County, being inhabited for over 200 years.  The Shupe House was built between 1812-1814 – a time before Lorain County was formed, and this location was rather Huron County.  Giant bark-covered logs serve as floor joists supported by a hand-cut sandstone foundation.  Many original aspects of the house remain today and have been carefully restored and maintained.

The early post-and-beam frame structure was built with the help of Shupe’s early up-and-down sash style thundershower sawmill operated by an undershot waterwheel powered by Beaver Creek.  The sawmill, started in 1811, was expanded with a gristmill operation in 1813 (we maintain one of the original granite gristmill stones or mill buhrs here at the Homestead).  Jacob Shupe was responsible for starting industry and spurring development in this northern Lorain County area and ought to be recognized for such.  Previous to this, area settlers would have to travel great distances to get their grain ground or lumber sawn.  Mr. Shupe shortened these settlers’ trips and allowed the log house to give way to a more modern frame house.  Mrs. Shupe was quite a pioneer woman herself, raising a family of 11 children, making many items for the family homestead, and helping her husband operate the mills.  Jacob Shupe was killed in an accident while making an extension to his mill when a piece of lumber fell on him in 1832.  He was 54.

After the address by Col. Nahorn to unveil and dedicate the historical marker, visitors were welcomed to stand within the walls of the oldest area house; tasty refreshments were enjoyed by those in attendance; and an open house at the New Indian Ridge Museum ensued.  The Museum’s collection of antique tractors and hit-and-miss engines was also displayed, and some engines were demonstrated.  It is an honor and pleasure to live at this historic homestead.

“Chronicle-Telegram” reporter Steve Fogarty captured well the reasons for the historical marker and dedication ceremony:


“What is a Watershed?” Learn all about it!

A well-vegetated riparian buffer at the Historic Shupe Homestead in Amherst.

A well-vegetated riparian buffer at the Historic Shupe Homestead in Amherst.

Want to know what is a watershed?  Want to know how the ways in which you use your property affect water quality and stream issues, such as erosion?  Please plan to attend this upcoming program!  Col. Nahorn (B.A., Environmental Studies, Oberlin College), Director of the New Indian Ridge Museum & 1811 Historic Shupe Homestead Wildlife Preserve, Vice President of the Amherst Historical Society, and an environmental issues consultant will present, “What is a Watershed: Landuse Affects Water Quality & Stream Bank Integrity” for the Pittsfield Historical Society’s General Membership Meeting.

Please plan to attend the 7pm Thursday, October 13th meeting at the Pittsfield Township Hall near the corner of Routes 58 & 303 in Pittsfield.  We hope you can join us!

Learn more about watersheds by following this link, below:

Beaver Creek Watershed


Longtime “Angelo’s Pizza” Building Demolished


The southeast corner of Church Street and Tenney Avenue in Amherst has been home to numerous businesses over the years.  Most recently, from about 1973-2001, it was home to the famous Angelo’s Pizza restaurant (301 Church St.).  Col. Nahorn recalls enjoying many tasty pizza-related meals in that establishment over the years.  Previously, the building – and the lot itself – was home to several other businesses.

Years before, a grain elevator operated on this spot.  The first grain elevator-grist mill combined operation was built on this site c.1858.  It has been noted that farmers came there to grind, store, and sell their grain from this operation, which was steam-powered.  It is documented in early newspapers that that building burned down in 1864 when a coal-fired train engine came by, spewing out sparks, leading to a fire.  (The newspaper article appeared in the Thursday, June 9, 1864 edition of the “Cleveland Daily Leader” under the headline “Fire in North Amherst.”)  At this time, the train tracks were still at ground level.  The steam grist mill and saw mill, owned by Mr. M. S. Hitchcock, of Elyria, and the Foundry and Plow Factory, of the Kendeigh brothers, were completely destroyed by fire “Tuesday night” (June 7, 1864).  The loss, at that time, was estimated to be $10-12,000, and they were uninsured.

The grain elevator was then rebuilt in a different building style, as an impressive three-story steam gristmill.  In May of 1897 this structure, owned by John Gerlach, caught on fire and was also destroyed.  It had been rented from Gerlach to Ben Wiegand (Wiegant), and Kinsey and Bivins had had interest in the operation.  The area was cleaned up, and a building was moved to this site, likely from next door, to the east.  It is possible but not confirmed that this building was the original Amherst Fire barn, where the Fire Department once operated (originally, however, located on South R.R. St. and Lewis St. – the area now known as Maple St. – and moved from that site c.1880) and dated somewhere in the mid-1800s.

Brucker’s Blacksmith shop then occupied this “new” building.  Later, “heavy and light trucking” was operated out of this spot, according to a 1919 advertisement for Zilch Transfer Line in the “Amherst News-Times.”  (The original front portion of the structure (peaked roof portion) likely dated to the mid-1800s).  This building was remodeled into Dangle Dairy, operated by Wm. Dangle, who later sold it to Wm. Baetz.  Baetz Dairy operated here from about 1922-1952.  A few other businesses operated here, including Amherst Photo Studio, Brown’s Studio & Camera, Evan’s Photo Studio, Tommy’s Rec (block section of the building), Elaine Kay Beauty Shop, The Beauty Nook, Ace Interiors, Turner’s Music, and also Amon’s Music, until Angelo’s Pizza and Restaurant opened in 1973.

The building, empty for several years, was condemned by the City of Amherst.  On July 12-13, 2016, demolition occurred.  A group of interested citizens and local historians gathered to witness the event.  Square nail construction was found in the front portion, during demolition, confirming beliefs in the age of the building.  Further, the window located in the peak of the oldest section of the building, facing Church Street, was able to be salvaged by Col. Nahorn for the Museum, and upon inspection, it was noted the glass is quite wavy, confirming suspicion of an aged window.  We are most pleased to have the window now preserved at the New Indian Ridge Museum, as it was often prominently featured in photographic views of the building over the years.

A special thank you to D. & L. Construction, Charlie Marty, Jim Wilhelm, Mark Haff, and Bill Nahorn for aiding in the salvage of the window.  Thanks also to Jim Wilhelm, Joan Rosenbusch, and Fay Van Nuys Ott for aiding in the historical research leading to the completion of this article.



Lorain Block Bricks


The Lorain Brick Co. and Kilns were located across the Black River from Bungart Island.  This company made road paving bricks.  The Brick Company was incorporated Feb. 13, 1904 (but it is shown on the 1896 Lorain County map, below).

Bricks made at this factory, marked “Lorain Block,” are relatively rare finds.  We located a few of these bricks at the Shupe Homestead in a long-forgotten pile of bricks.  This was a very unique and interesting find, and we thank our brick advisor and specialist Debbie Slavik for her information and insight into this brick company and other brick information she has furnished the Museum.


Black River Restoration Reviewed

As a member of the Black River Area of Concern, Col. Nahorn attended this organization’s quarterly meeting in July 2016 in order to aid in moving the business of the group forward and also discuss and view some of the latest stream bank restoration projects in the lower Black River.  These restoration projects include re-vegetating stream banks with native plants and trees; re-creating rocky ledges known as “fish shelves” for fish breeding and shelter; and floodplain restoration.  After the potluck meal and subsequent business meeting, a boat tour was taken of the lower Black River from the Landing upriver to just beyond Bungart Island.  Restoration sites were pointed out, and a few may be noted below:

Stream bank restoration with native plantings and rock stabilization walls.

Stream bank restoration with native plantings and rock stabilization walls (after finding a seep).

Great blue heron rookery area, adjacent to floodplain restoration sites. Nearly 300 nests have been logged here, along this bend in the Canesadooharie.

Great blue heron rookery area, adjacent to floodplain restoration sites. Nearly 300 nests have been logged here, along this bend in the Canesadooharie.

Stream bank restoration site.

Stream bank restoration site.

Finally, we welcome the LoCo Yak group and thank them for their deeper participation in the furtherance of this important action group.  Much has been accomplished over the years, and we appreciate the LoCo Yaks for their dedication and choice to step forward at this crucial moment.

Chip Rathwell First Americans Paleo Display Named


Kind, generous, funny, and dedicated are words that come to mind when I remember my friend, Chip Rathwell.

A Vietnam Veteran, Chip served his country honorably and selflessly.  A knowledgeable teacher, historian, friend, and family man, Chip was dedicated to all of his endeavors and those around him.  He passed from this world on May 29, 2016.

Following is a brief history compiled by Lorain County historian and genealogist Jeff Sigsworth: “Cousin Irving Merle “Chip” Rathwell, Jr. (1947-2016) of Amherst, U.S. Navy veteran, longtime teacher (particularly spending years in the field of welding), Amherst Historical Society Trustee, and my colleague at Monday night Amherst Historical Research Group meetings. Condolences to and prayers for his wife of 43 years, Cathy J. (Zakutny) Rathwell, his children, and extended family.  Chip was a son of Irving M. Sr. & Doris L. (Moore) Rathwell; grandson of Edwin E. & Eva Fannie (Edwards) Rathwell; great-grandson of Thomas & Eliza Jane (McRoberts) Rathwell; and great-great-grandson of James & Prudence (Clark) McRoberts of Springfield & Hubbardton, Vt., and Pittsfield Twp., Lorain Co., Ohio.”

In 2013 Chip donated significant artifacts to the New Indian Ridge Museum, which, of note, allowed for our Paleo display to grow and encompass two Paleo-era artifacts that were found right here in Lorain County.  These pieces, found on his family farm by his father, and the information they provide for local archaeology are beyond monetary value.  That is why the Paleo display in the Museum will now be known as the “Chip Rathwell First Americans Paleo Display,” in honor of our good friend, Chip Rathwell and his steadfast support in the documentation and preservation of local, early history.  He will be missed but not forgotten.  Particularly, each of us ought to remember his self-less service to our country.


Photos courtesy Charlie Marty. 

Watershed Open House

Once again this March, the Friends of Vermilion River Watershed will host a free, open house event at the Historic Vermilion-on-the-Lake Clubhouse.  It is the tenth annual such event.

Please mark your calendars for Saturday, March 19 any time from 10am-4pm to stop out and browse nature- and watershed awareness-oriented exhibits.  One of the major attractions is a wildlife exhibit created by the Back to the Wild wildlife rehabilitation center of Castalia.  They will bring live wildlife for exhibit and educational purposes.  Usually, some type of wildlife that has been rehabilitated will be released during the afternoon.

Col. Nahorn will also again be attending and exhibiting, representing the Beaver Creek Watershed Protection Group (an affiliate group of the New Indian Ridge Museum, focusing on watershed awareness and low-impact development within the Watershed) and also West River Paddle Sports, where he serves as a naturalist and tour guide.

Please plan to attend.  This will be a fun and informative event, as always.

See flyer, below: 

Please click the image to enlarge

Kitchen Island of Salvaged Historic Material – a New Item Built of Old

Three unrelated historic salvage projects contributed to the construction of a feature piece of furniture for the Historic Shupe House.  We recently finished and installed a new kitchen island and are very pleased with the outcome.


The legs were cut from a single hand-hewn structural beam collected from a house on Beaver Court here in Amherst.  Thanks to a generous donation by Ed Fridenstine, we were able to acquire a few nicely preserved hand-hewn beams.  Renovations by Mr. Fridenstine led to the opportunity for us to salvage some of these structural items.  Interestingly, several 19th century shoes were also found in this Beaver Court residence, as a Mr. Uthe once operated a cobbler shop in a portion of this house.  The bead board that comprises the sides was salvaged from Amherst’s first town hall and union school building. Originally a two-story wood frame house built c. 1830, the building was donated for use as a town hall and lecture room by early Amherst settler and prominent citizen, Justice of the Peace Josiah Harris.  The structure, after having multiple uses over the years, had been moved once and suffered two large fires during its history, was demolished in 2015 to make room for the new Brew Kettle restaurant next to the Amherst Theatre.  We were able to retain the original green/blue paint color and unique painted numbers on the boards, once we reassembled them on the cabinet.  The two drawers were salvaged from the historic Wadsworth House in Wellington.  D. L. Wadsworth built the house c. 1866, and after having been moved with intentions to save it, the house was demolished in 2012.  We repainted the drawer fronts white and stripped most of the paint off of the unique metal drawer pulls, leaving some green paint as accents.  The white drawers and hardware accent the other features of the island quite nicely.  The only “new” and purchased item incorporated into the island is the beautiful green, white, and rust-colored granite top we ordered.

From planning stages to the finished item, the project took just a few months.   We are very pleased to have been able to not only salvage these important items but to create a new piece of history with materials of such historic significance.  Old history is now creating a brand new item.  What a neat historically-oriented addition to the Homestead!  February 2016.

Haff Piano Desk Acquired

The Museum continuously acquires unique items of various sizes, from a tiny, ancient fossil to a giant, colossal grist stone.  The subject of this article is no different in its uniqueness.


On January 17, 2016, we officially acquired a very unique furniture item – a desk that had been made from the case of an antique piano.  This square grand piano converted into a desk had been used in the real estate office of Raymond Haff from 1975-1990 as Mr. Haff’s main desk at his 101 Park Ave., downtown Amherst office.  It had been acquired by Mr. Haff at an auction in South Amherst.  After the real estate office closed in 1990 due to Mr. Haff’s retirement, the desk found a new home at the Haff residence, also in Amherst.


The Museum was given the opportunity to acquire this extremely different item just a few weeks ago.  We soon made arrangements as we could not pass up this piece of art and history.  The acquisition became a reality, thanks to the generous financial donation to secure the item by Ms. Cindy Kohart, a friend of the Museum.  The famous Haff desk, made out of an antique piano case, was moved to the New Indian Ridge Museum, January 17th.  We thank Mark Haff (son of Mr. Raymond Haff), and his mother, Mrs. Ruth Haff (wife of the late Mr. Raymond Haff) for offering the opportunity to acquire this interesting piece of art and history, to the Museum.  A special thank you to Museum Board Member Bill Nahorn for helping to move the item and to engineer the move.  Finally, thank you to local photographer Jason Shaffer, also a friend of the Museum, for his crucial aid in moving the desk into the Museum, down a set of very steep steps.  Wow, what a great team!

When viewing photos of the desk, we direct you to the closed view, below, showing inlaid wooden lettering and stars on the top.  Further research into the history of the desk, its manufacturer, and the significance of these inlays is forthcoming.  The resulting research will be posted in an updated version of this article.


Below, in the process of moving the desk


Photo courtesy Mark Haff.

Next Page »